£500 'smart' powers meters for all which could let energy firms cap use in homes

By Sean Poulter
Last updated at 10:14 AM on 30th November 2009


'Smart meters' for gas and electricity are set to be approved for installation across the country in a huge project that could cost homes and businesses more than £500 each.

The meters are being presented as the key to doing away with estimated bills and encouraging families to cut down on their energy use by showing them how much they are using.

The huge scheme is to be unveiled by Climate Change Secretary, Ed Miliband, as part of a package of measures to cut the nation's carbon footprint ahead of the climate change summit in Copenhagen.

meters for all

Smart meters: How the new scheme will work

However, the cost of installation has been estimated by the Government at £9billion, while some analysts suggest the figure will be as high as £13.4billion.

Consumer groups fear that the major part of this bill will be passed on to housholders and could add up to £515 per family over a ten-year period.

The smart meters, to be installed by 2020, will allow power giants to read meters remotely, most likely via a link to the mobile phone network.

It will be possible to send an electronic message to the meters to change the tariffs in line with price alterations.

It will also allow companies to charge more during peak times. The meters could also be used to ration supplies across the network or cap electricity use in a particular household to a certain threshold.

electric meter

Out with the old: Older-style electric meters will be phased out to make way for new 'smart' meters

 

The Government claims that its estimate of £9billion for the cost would be more than covered by some £11.79 billion in savings.

It is suggested suppliers would save £6.6billion through cutting the thousands of people needed to read meters and man customer call centres.

And householders are predicted to save £3.1billion because, in theory, they would cut consumption once they could see how much electricity and gas they use.

It was claimed there would be further savings of just over £2billion, giving a final total of £11.79billion.

However, analysts at accountants Ernst & Young said the costing for the massive scheme had failed to reflect the true scale of the enterprise.

Its utilities expert, Tony Ward, said: 'Very big and complex projects of this sort always cost more than anticipated.'

Mr Ward said it would be a hugely difficult, expensive and time-consumingjob to gain access to all 26million UK properties to install the new meters. He stressed that there will be vast initial costs to buy the equipment and set up the infrastructure to collect the readings.

Dr Fiona Cochrane, energy campaigner for consumer group Which?, said: 'We don't see how the Government can justify asking consumers to pay for something that will save energy companies hundreds of millions a year, while the average household will make only minimal savings.'



 

Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have not been moderated.

This will mean that the consumer bills will have to go up to pay for the new technology regardless of who pays for the original equipment are we all that blinkered about climate change!

Click to rate     Rating   2

I cannot believe that we are to go ahead with this hair-brained scheme (yet another green box ticked). Yes, we have to address the issue of global warming, but any "solutions" should be democratically sanctioned. Problems have arisen elsewhere in the world over this unpopular (and potentially harmful) practice - but one fact is being overlooked which, alone, is sufficient to send this scheme back to the drawing board - "Lord" Truscott's covert involvement in the Bill to push for these installations (on behalf of Industry). Have we not had enough of fiscal influence on our lives?

Sylvia Wright

Click to rate     Rating   4

If they save the companies money then I don't see why they don't install them free. One company already does.

Click to rate     Rating   2

The needlessly frequent mobile radio transmission of the proposed 'smart' meters will certainly cause adverse health consequences for very many people.

Possible annual bill saving - £40 / year, at best, Cost of new 'smart' meter to be dumped on all consumers - £50+ / year for ten years. Power company profits are too important to be wasted on paying for their cash flow acceleration scam.

Click to rate     Rating   5

The poll concerning: "Should energy companies be forced to foot the bill for installing smart meters?" - is valueless as we the consumer will end up paying directly or indirectly - all the power company has to do is tweak their tariffs and we end up paying for the meter and it's installation!

Click to rate     Rating   6

I suppose these new meters are made in China which if like the mistake of introduction of mercury filled light bulbs (poisonous) will prove to be a disastrously expensive solution to the problem ---what problem?. So the Govt is prepared to put meter readers out of jobs....it seems to me any crackpot scheme is ok by the current administration because they don't have the intelligence to be able to put a stop to these basicvally wrong inventions. Then we each have to pay £500 for the priviledge!. Absolutely mad.

Click to rate     Rating   5

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Your name and location will appear next to your comment.
You have 1000 characters left.
We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.
For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.
Terms