Skip over navigation
Advanced Search

Man spends 18 hours in police cell and has his DNA taken for 'dropping an apple core'

By JAMES TOZER - More by this author » Last updated at 19:09pm on 9th May 2008

Comments Comments (61)

He only popped out to run a couple of errands for his disabled wife.

But Keith Hirst ended up spending the night in a police cell after being accused of dropping an apple core.

Despite strenuously denying the allegation, the former plumber, who has a heart condition, was taken into custody by up to five uniformed officers and had his DNA and fingerprints taken.

Scroll down for more...

Keith Hirst

Keith Hirst, who has a heart condition, was locked up for 18 hours

By then his worried family were calling hospitals, fearing he had been in an accident.

It wasn't until nearly 11pm that he was able to ring them and explain what had happened.

He was finally released after 18 hours behind bars.

Mr Hirst, 54, said yesterday he would fight to clear his name in a case which could leave him with a criminal record and cost taxpayers thousands of pounds.

"The way I was treated you would have thought I had robbed a bank," he said.

"My family are law-abiding people and I would help if I saw a gang of yobs attacking a police officer.

"This kind of incident does not help in improving relations between the community and police."

Mr Hirst had just come out of a post office near his home in Swinton, Greater Manchester, and was heading for the chemists to collect his wife's prescription when a community support officer accused him of littering.

He said the officer wanted to issue him with a £50 on-the-spot fine for littering.

"There was a chap there in a fluorescent jacket, big sunglasses, and a baseball cap, on a bike, with a wad of tickets and a pen. He said, 'Why did you drop that apple core?' and I told him I didn't drop an apple core.

"He then said he wanted my name and address. He was an over-zealous young lad, baying to give me a ticket.

"I told him I was on my way to the shops but would be walking back that way if he wanted to speak to me later."

Mr Hirst says that when he emerged from the chemists he claimed he was surrounded by five uniformed officers.

"I said I had done nothing wrong and so was not telling them who I was," he said.

He was taken to the police station, where his belongings were taken and his DNA and finger-prints recorded before being locked in the cells overnight.

He twice had to be seen by a doctor after complaining of dizziness and chest pains.

After being charged with littering and obstructing a police officer, the following morning he was handcuffed to a security guard to appear before local magistrates.

His wife, whose disability is due to a back problem, said: "The first I knew about it was when Keith called at 10.45pm.

"He'd gone to the Post Office at lunchtime. We did not know where he was and my daughter had been ringing hospitals. The whole case is ridiculous."

A police source claimed Mr Hirst had flung the apple core across the road, almost hitting someone.

The source added that Mr Hirst refused to give his details to a single officer called in by the PCSO as back-up after he behaved rudely and aggressively. This officer requested two more officers to arrest him.

If he had provided his address he would have been released from custody, the source added.

The obstruction charge was subsequently dropped but Mr Hirst is due to face trial before a district judge for the alleged littering offence last month.

He could face a £2,500 fine or up to six months in prison.

Superintendent Ian Palmer, of Greater Manchester Police, said: "Littering is an offence. We work tirelessly to ensure the streets are not only safe but also clean."

Earlier this year, the Daily Mail told how Kate Badger, 25, from Wolverhampton, was taken to court after being accused of throwing an apple core from her car.

The case, which dragged on for a year at a cost of at least £2,800, was later dropped.

Last month, Sarah Davies, 20, was fined £75 after dropping a piece of sausage roll she was feeding to her four-year-old daughter in Hull.

Comment Add your comment | View all Comments (61)

61 people have commented on this story so far. Tell us what you think below.

Here's a sample of the latest comments published. You can click view all to read all comments that readers have sent in.

Nice to see the police are concentrating on catching the real criminals again!

- Mark Leck, Hartlepool

Five Police officers and a Community support officer beggars belief. These people should be fined for wasting public money on this. Is it any wonder the public have no respect for the police or the law? This is just legal robbery.

- Norm, Newcastle, UK

Another soft touch for lunacy.

- Keith, Shropshire

View all Add your comment


make text area biggerYou have  characters left.

Mail to a friend Print story Read later


©2008 Associated Newspapers Ltd · Terms & Conditions · Privacy
Femail wino

Amy Winehouse strips off in the sunshine to reveal her shockingly skinny frame
Amy Winehouse cut a shocking picture running through a park looking bony and gaunt. She was snapped behind a recording studio in Henley, Oxfordshire

beatrice

Queen Bea: Princess Beatrice wins the style stakes at the polo
The chic young royal easily outshone a bunch of D-list celebs, including Danielle Lloyd, Ingrid Tarrant and Esther Rantzen - who had forgotten to remove the tag from her dress
From boozing to bowler hats: Prince Harry recovers from late night to smarten up for military parade

SJP

Chic geek: Ugly duckling Sarah Jessica Parker may not have quite turned into a swan
Pictures of the young actress show she's the ultimate chic geek
Sex and the shower scene... or how Kristin Davis refused to bare all in Sex And The City movie

aniston

Poolside passion for Jennifer Aniston and her new man
Jennifer Aniston caused ripples in a Miami swimming pool when she got up close and personal with her new man, tattooed rocker John Mayer

brit

Baby one more time? Britney's swollen belly sparks new pregnancy rumours
Britney Spears has sparked fresh pregnancy rumours after she was snapped cradling her swollen-looking stomach on a shopping trip

owen

Owen Wilson to wed Kate Hudson - a year after he 'tried to kill himself' when she dumped him
Hollywood A-listers Kate Hudson and Owen Wilson are set to tie the knot – a year after he allegedly tried to kill himself when she dumped him

adoption

Can money buy you love? One woman's story about the expensive decision to adopt a child from abroad... and make herself a single parent
Career woman and singleton Kate Spicer is planning to adopt a child at 38. Here she explains why

summer dresses

The new dress code: Sizzling summer styles for every shape and size
Mini or maxi, bodycon or one-shouldered, tea or shift? We give you the lowdown on the hottest summer dress styles which will leave others in the shade


DON'T MISS...

harry in a bowler

From boozing to bowler hats: Prince Harry recovers from late night to smarten up for military parade

Hours earlier, he'd bowled out of a nightclub, slightly more bleary-eyed
chelsy

Chelsy Davy gets a makeover as she prepares to meet the Queen

Harry's girlfriend ditches the miniskirts and the Red Bull before being introduced to HRH
lindsay lohan

Lindsay Lohan strikes a pose in tiger-print to launch her new line of leggings

Singer, actress... and now designer. Is there no end to the 21-year-old starlet's talents?
kelly

The single life suits Kelly Brook and Billy Zane as they grin from ear to ear and go their separate ways

The smiling model was in Kent wearing skimpy shorts and some snug Ugg boots
dixon

Springtime heat puts Alesha Dixon in the gutter after West End night out

Normally effortless at maintaining gracious moves, Alesha got clumsy on a night out in the West End
coleen

Midnight blue Coleen paints Manchester red for the 'mother' of all hen parties

Wayne Rooney's fiancée Coleen McLoughlin takes friends AND mum along for her hen party
russell brand and blonde

Russell Brand spotted on a romantic date with a mystery LA lady

The self-confessed sex addict seemed smitten as the pair chatted over a Greek meal
pete

Bleary-eyed Pete Doherty celebrates prison release by partying with mystery brunette

The singer looked like he had well and truly put ex-love Kate Moss behind him
zucker

Nice place for a WAG wedding: Joe Cole to wed Carly Zucker at London's Royal Hospital

England star Joe and his fiancée plan a pure premier league party
sugar

How Sir Alan Sugar celebrated his 40th wedding anniversary with a £2m party

The tycoon's celebration starred Brucie, Elton and some very corny jokes
peaches geldof

I kid you not... Peaches keeps sis Pixie OUT of trouble

Peaches, 19, has been acting as self-appointed guardian to younger sister Pixie on their nights out
sienn

Wedding on ice as Sienna Miller plays it cool with 'jealous' Rhys Ifans

Talk of a summer wedding for Sienna and her boyfriend Rhys always seemed a little premature